By Nadav Shragai, Ha'aretz, 31 October 2000
![]()
A few days ago, someone posted the
poem by poet Yitzhak Shalev, "I See
Barricades," on one of the billboards in the town of Efrat, where last
Thursday in early morning hours the Tifferet Avot (Glory of the
Patriarchs) synagogue was desecrated:."I see barricades rising again on
the
road to Efrata," wrote Shalev 12 years ago, after the signing of the Camp
David agreements, "Ghost barricades arise from the land of 1948 / And I
see a
narrow opening, and a line where Jews wait / For the soldier's permission
to come
to Rachel's Tomb / And a green flag flies over the Tomb / And all the camps
of
Palestine are spread out in a battalion / And I hear again the voice, the
voice of
bitter weeping / Rachel is mourning her sons..."
The "green flag" (of Islamic fundamentalism) is not flying above
Rachel's Tomb
as yet, but except for that, Shalev's prophecies have been almost completely
realized. Almost every night, shooting battles take place around the tomb
compound. The IDF no longer allows Jews to visit, in spite of the fact
that the
compound, which is only 480 meters away from the area of Jerusalem's
jurisdiction, as well as the road to it, are defined as Area C (complete
Israeli
control). The students of the yeshiva... are also not allowed to go the
Tomb, which
has become a forward outpost of the IDF.
The anniversary of the death of Rachel will take place in another nine
days,
according to Jewish tradition, on the the 11th of Heshvan 5761 (November
9,
2000). Porat and his friends are not willing to accept the decree, and
have
already made a formal request to the prime minister to allow them to hold
a
"mass prayer meeting, as is done every year," and "to take all necessary
steps to guarantee the security of the worshipers."
The Palestinians who shoot at the compound every day have already singled
it out
as the next Jewish holy site which they want to "liberate." Already last
Yom
Kippur the Palestinian Authority newspaper Al Hayyat al Jedida published
an
article entitled: "After the liberation of Joseph's Tomb - Can we liberate
the Belal
ibn Rabakh mosque? (the Arabic name for Rachel's Tomb).
"Rachel's Tomb, or the Belal ibn Rabakh mosque," the article stated, "
is
one of the nails hammered into many Palestinian cities by the occupation
governments and the Zionist movement. The outpost lies at the northern
entrance to the town of Bethlehem. After the Oslo accords, the place became
a
military outpost surrounded by a beautiful marble wall, and a Jewish synagogue
and other rooms were built ....
"The Palestinians," reported Al Jedida, "affirm that this tomb is fake,
and
that it was originally a Muslim mosque ... until the occupation forces
captured the Palestinian territories and considered the place to be Rachel's
Tomb. The question is whether after the evacuation of Joseph's Tomb in
Nablus, the Palestinians will succeed in forcing the occupation to evacuate
Rachel's Tomb as well."
In sermons given in the mosques, the mosque is also referred to as the
next
brick which must be removed from the Jewish-Zionist edifice, after Joseph's
Tomb.
IDF soldiers posted in the compound do not read Al Hayyat al Jedida, and
they hear the muezzins only from a distance, but the comparison between
Joseph's Tomb and Rachel's Tomb angers many of them. "Rachel is the mother.
Joseph is the son," said one of the soldiers, sharing his feelings.
"Joseph," added his friend, "is buried in Nablus, out of sight, out of
mind.
The place reserved here for Mother Rachel is entirely different from that
which was reserved for the tomb of Joseph."
An observant Jew, a resident of the nearby Gilo neighborhood, who tried
on
Friday to go to the compound in order to pray there, heard for the first
time from the soldiers that the tomb has been closed already for several
weeks. "And Rachel died, and was buried on the way to Efrat, which is
Bethlehem," the man started reading from the book of Genesis, in front
of
the soldiers at the barricade. "And Jacob set a tombstone upon her grave,"
the man continued, "that is the tombstone of Rachel's tomb to this day."
The
soldiers very politely followed orders. "You can't go through," they
explained to him patiently. "They're shooting."
After the Six-Day War, Rachel's Tomb was almost annexed to Jerusalem and
included within the sovereign border of the State of Israel. Only a few
hundred meters separate the barricade at the southern exit from the city
and the
site, which was sanctified by Jews for so many generations. Levi Eshkol,
as prime
minister in 1967, instructed his justice minister, Yaakov Shimshon Shapiro,
to
include the tomb within Jerusalem's new jurisdictional borders, and was
angry
when he discovered that his instructions had been ignored.
In his book "Jerusalem, A City Without a Wall," Uzi Benziman writes that
Shapiro considered the drawing of the borders a security issue only, and
that in such matters he always relied on Defense Minister Moshe Dayan.
Dayan
did not want to include Rachel's Tomb within Jerusalem's boundaries. He
was
supported by Interior Minister Moshe Haim Shapiro, who thought that
international sensitivity stemming from Israeli control of the Church of
the Holy
Sepulcher in the Old City was bad enough. Minister of Religious Affairs
Zerah
Wahrhaftig differed with them. He was not satisfied with Israeli control
over the
Church of the Holy Sepulcher, and wanted to transfer the Church of the
Nativity
in Bethelehem to Israeli control as well. In his opinion, the two places
which are
holy to the Christian world should be included within the borders of the
State of
Israel, "so that the Christian world would recognize [Israel's] importance.
But the ministerial committee which discussed the issue rejected his view
in
favor of that of the ministers of justice and the interior. Only half a
year
after the Six-Day War did Eshkol discover that his request had not been
honored, and that Rachel's Tomb had remained outside Jerusalem's borders.
Upset at what had happened, Eshkol investigated why his instructions had
not
been carried out.
Almost 30 years later, Rachel's Tomb was once again forgotten. The Israeli
negotiating team for talks with the Palestinians had already agreed to
include the tomb and its environs in the area of the city of Bethlehem,
which has been transferred to the complete control of the Palestinian
Authority. Only after the uproar raised by the religious parties, and
frequent meetings on the issue held with late Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin
and with his successor Shimon Peres, were the Israeli negotiators ordered
to
take back the agreement. This change "cost" Israel other concessions, which
the
Palestinians demanded in exchange, but finally the tomb remained under
Israeli
control, with a road hundreds of meters long separating it from the Gilo
barricade
in the south of the city.
The situation at Rachel's Tomb took on many different forms over the
generations. "The Unknown Tourist from Bordeaux" mentions it in the year
333
C.E., and a Christian tourist who visited the country in 670, tells of
the
tomb, which is in the form of a tombstone made of simple stones, without
any
ornamentation. Tourists in later generations tell of a tombstone made of
11
stones, one for each of Jacob's sons, and above it a dome built on four
columns. Another Jewish tourist, Rabbi Petahia, who passed through the
country in 1180, describes it: "And on her tomb there are 11 stones, one
for
each tribe, and because Benjamin was not born until she died, there is
no
stone for him..."
For several generations, the tombstone was under a round dome, built on
four
stone columns; only later did they build walls between the columns, which
were
surrounded by a small domed room, by special permission of the Turkish
ruler of
Jerusalem, Mohammed Pasha. In 1841, Sir Moses Montefiore received a permit
to repair Rachel's Tomb, from the Turkish authorities, who recognized the
place
as the holy property of the Jews. At the entrance to the tomb a heavy iron
door
was built, and the key was entrusted to a Jewish sexton. The room surrounding
the tombstone was renovated, and an additional room was built near the
existing
one. Thus Rachel's Tomb took on the shape which was familiar to us until
a few
years ago, before the wall was built around it.
The inscription on Rachel's Tomb to this day testifies to the assistance
given by Montefiore for renovation during that period: "The house which
was
built by the great minister in Israel Sir Moses Montefiore and his wife,
the
daughter of kings, Dame Judith, may they deserve to see our righteous
Messiah." Twenty years later, a cistern was dug nearby, to allow the many
visitors to the site to slake their thirst. After the Holocaust, the Chief
Rabbinate of Israel put up a large menorah lamp, which was hung in front
of
the tombstone and which contained an "eternal light," which was dedicated,
as written around the menorah: "To the elevation of the souls of tens of
thousands of Jewish martyrs, who were destroyed by the cursed evildoers,
may
their name be erased, during the years 1939-1945."
Charms, amulets and various prayers have been connected to Rachel's Tomb.
To
this day, their is a custom among women of circling the tomb with a red
string.
They believe that the string becomes sanctified because of its
contact with the tombstone, and later they tie it on their neck or hand,
as
a charm against the evil eye and illnesses. Sacks filled with earth
collected from around Rachel's Tomb were sold abroad during earlier
generations, and Jews used to ask before their deaths that this earth be
scattered around their graves. Pictures of the tomb were printed on coins,
postcards, books and stamps, and rabbis designated special prayers to be
said at the tomb. Many poems were written about Rachel's Tomb, and for
generations Jews made great efforts to buy land there.
During the first years of the Intifada, members of the Gush Etzion regional
council managed to buy back ownership of about 10 dunams of Jewish-owned
land
near Rachel's Tomb, which had been taken over by Arabs. This is apparently
land
acquired by Nathan Strauss and Rabbi Zvi Kalischer during the last century.
In
Zev Vilnai's book "Holy Tombstones in the Land of Israel," these acquisitions
are recorded. "Rachel's Tomb and the holiness of its environs," he wrote,
"aroused among Jews already at the beginning of the Lovers of Zion movement,
the desire to acquire property here and to settle on it. Through the intervention
of
Rabbi Zvi Kalischer, who was head of the Land of Israel Settlement committee,
Rabbi Mordechai Yaffe managed to buy a plot of land near Rachel's Tomb."
After almost being handed over to the Palestinians about five years ago,
the
tomb compound and the access road are now included within the boundaries
of all
the final agreement maps drawn by Israeli cartographers of every
political persuasion. Even on Barak's map the tomb remains within Israel,
and will be annexed to it
(Translation courtesy of IMRA http://www.imra.org.il)
The Committee For
Rachel's Tomb
David Landau, Director,
P.O. Box 1029, Derech Efrata, 90435, Israel
rachtomb@netvision.net.il
Fax: 972-2-960-5008
Rachel's Tomb: A Capsule History A Photographic Tour Of Rachel's Tomb Searching For Every Rachel More Recent History
Rachel's Yahrzeit News Update Articles
Midnight At The Tomb Prayers For Those In Need Donations Links Webmaster